| Team name | Location | League | Level | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Newark Peppers | Newark, New Jersey | Federal League | professional | defunct |
| Pimento Peppers | Pimento, Indiana | high school | active | |
| Salinas Peppers | Salinas, California | Western Baseball League | professional | defunct |
| Shadeland Peppers | Shadeland, Indiana | high school | defunct | |
| Wallace Peppers | Wallace, Indiana | high school | defunct |