| Boston Pilgrims |
Boston, Massachusetts |
Major League Baseball |
professional |
defunct |
| Brockton Pilgrims |
Brockton, Massachusetts |
Colonial League |
professional |
defunct |
| Davenport Pilgrims |
Davenport, Iowa |
Two-I League |
professional |
defunct |
| Lansing Christian Pilgrims |
Lansing, Michigan |
|
high school |
active |
| Natchez Pilgrims |
Natchez, Mississippi |
Evangeline League |
professional |
defunct |
| New England College Pilgrims |
Henniker, New Hampshire |
|
college |
active |
| New England Pilgrims |
New Haven, Connecticut |
American Professional Slow Pitch League |
professional |
defunct |
| New Plymouth Pilgrims |
New Plymouth, Idaho |
|
high school |
active |
| Plymouth Pilgrims |
Plymouth, Massachusetts |
New England Collegiate Baseball League |
amateur |
defunct |
| Plymouth Pilgrims |
Plymouth, Indiana |
|
high school |
active |