| Team name | Location | League | Level | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Anchor Bay Tars | Fair Haven, Michigan | high school | active | |
| Denby Tech Prep Tars | Detroit, Michigan | high school | active | |
| Jacksonville Tars | Jacksonville, Florida | South Atlantic League | professional | defunct |
| Jacksonville Tars | Jacksonville, Florida | Southeastern League | professional | defunct |
| Jacksonville Tars | Jacksonville, Florida | Southern League | professional | defunct |
| Ludington Tars | Ludington, Michigan | Michigan State League | professional | defunct |
| Ludington Tars | Ludington, Michigan | Central League | professional | defunct |
| Norfolk Tars | Norfolk, Virginia | Eastern League | professional | defunct |
| Norfolk Tars | Norfolk, Virginia | Piedmont League | professional | defunct |
| Norfolk Tars | Norfolk, Virginia | Virginia League | professional | defunct |
| Rollins College Tars | Winter Park, Florida | college | active | |
| South Shore Tars | Chicago, Illinois | high school | active | |
| Tarboro Tars | Tarboro, North Carolina | Coastal Plain League | professional | defunct |