| Team name | Location | League | Level | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| C.S. Lewis Academy Watchmen | Newberg, Oregon | high school | active | |
| Calvary Christian Academy Watchmen | Montgomery, Alabama | high school | active | |
| Elgin Watchmen | Elgin, Minnesota | high school | defunct | |
| Elgin-Millville Watchmen | Elgin, Minnesota | high school | defunct | |
| Temple Christian Watchmen | Lewisville, Texas | high school | active |